HES: QUERY--Authorship of "Sketches on Political Economy" (1809)

Goncalo Fonseca walrasiad at gmail.com
Tue Nov 13 15:08:17 EST 2007


Hello HESers,

I have a quick question rel. to a fortuitous Googling exercise.

In his "Some Neglected British Economists, Pt. 1" (1903, EJ, Vol. 13,
p.338), E.R.A. Seligman refers to a 1809 volume entitled "Sketches on
Political Economy, illustrative of the interests of Great Britain:
intended as a reply to Mr. Mill's pamphlet Commerce Defended, with an
exposition of some leading tenets of the Economists", which has some
highly proto-marginalist content.  The author is anonymous, and
Seligman doesn't venture a guess.

Has the author of that tract ever been established?  The reason I ask
is that I stumbled upon a Monthly Review article from February 1813
that reviews a 1811 book called "The History of Aberdeen" written by a
certain "Walter Thom, author of Sketches on Political Economy, &c.".
Googlebooks happens to have a copy of that book online:

http://books.google.com/books?id=_g8vAAAAMAAJ

and the attribution is there, although the title remains shortened by
&c., so it is not certain it is the same book.

If this Walter Thom is indeed the author, has he been identified before?

And does anybody know anything about this fellow?

Goncalo Fonseca



More information about the HES mailing list